Rev. Thomas R. Taylor 01/01/1878 – 04/01/1884
Rev. Frank C. Colby 12/01/1884 - 10/01/1892
Rev. Z. Clark Martin 12/01/1893 – 03/21/1902
Rev. John Love, D.D. 05/01/1902 – 08/01/1905
Rev. J. Wesley Sullivan 08/01/1905 – 11/01/1906
Rev. Marshall McDuffie, D.D. 11/01/1906 – 02/15/1912
Rev. William Atchley, D.D. 06/18/1912 – 02/01/1919
Rev. David MacMurray 06/18/1919 – 10/15/1930
Rev. C. Gordon Browning, D.D. 10/15/1930 – 09/28/1935
Rev. F. Russell Purdy, D.D. 12/29/1935 – 10/29/1944
Rev. Norman W. Paulin, D.D. 03/11/1945 – 03/17/1948
Dr. John W. Hyssong 10/24/1948 – 03/01/1957
Rev. Gerald L. Stover 09/08/1957 – 09/06/1959
Rev. John P. Ludlum 02/01/1960 – 07/31/1969
Rev. Richard Sparling 06/29/1970 – 04/08/1971
Rev. David G. Unger 03/01/1972 – 12/31/1985
Rev. Richard T. Carnes 01/11/1987 – 07/26/1992
Rev. David V. Tosi 02/06/1994 – 07/06/2003
Rev. Norville Joshua Rich 08/08/2004 – 08/31//2011
Rev. John Helm 10/14/2013 -10/21/2019
Rev. Felix Flavien 11/01/2021-Present